BlogGeneral

Is Social Media Screening Legal? What Employers Need to Know

Yes, when it's done the right way. What the FCRA, state password laws and anti-discrimination rules require.

A brass balance scale on a dark desk, in navy and amber light.
Table of contents
  1. Does the FCRA apply to social media background checks?
  2. What does an employer have to do under the FCRA?
  3. Can employers ask for social media passwords?
  4. Can social media screening lead to discrimination claims?
  5. Can employers act on employees' posts about work?
  6. What should employers look for in a social media screening provider?
  7. When it becomes risky
  8. Expert Q&A: the legal landscape of social media screening
    1. What are the legal advantages of running a social media background check?
    2. Does federal or state law bar the use of social media for screening employees?
    3. Does social media screening raise concerns under Title VII or state discrimination laws?
    4. Have courts faulted employers for not considering social media?
    5. Why should employers consider outsourcing social media background checks?
    6. Does the FCRA apply to social media checks?
    7. If the FCRA applies, what procedures must employers follow?
    8. When should employers incorporate social media screening into hiring?
    9. Has the distinction between public and private social media been litigated?
    10. How do you avoid misjudging behavior across cultures and generations?
    11. Is there a use case for a social media check that doesn't fall under the FCRA?
    12. Does the FCRA apply to volunteer checks?
    13. Can screening be used during an internal investigation?
    14. What does the dispute process look like?
  9. FAQ
  10. The bottom line

Yes. Social media screening is legal in the United States when it is done the right way. Employers can review public social media content. When a third-party provider prepares the report, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) applies: the candidate must be told and must agree in writing. Decisions can never be based on protected characteristics such as race, religion, age or disability. And 28 states bar employers from asking for social media passwords.

Does the FCRA apply to social media background checks?

Yes, when a third-party provider prepares the report for employment decisions. In 2011 the Federal Trade Commission reviewed a social media screening company and found it was a consumer reporting agency, because it assembled information that employers used to decide whether someone was eligible for a job. The FTC said FCRA obligations “apply equally in the social networking context.” (FTC letter, 2011)

In 2012 the FTC fined Spokeo $800,000 for selling profiles built from online and social media data to employers without following the FCRA. It was the first FCRA case involving online data used for employee screening. (Inside Privacy, on the FTC’s Spokeo order)

Ferretly operates as a consumer reporting agency and follows the FCRA’s requirements for the reports it provides. See how Ferretly handles FCRA compliance.

What does an employer have to do under the FCRA?

Four steps, in order:

  1. Disclose. Give the candidate a clear written notice, in a document by itself, that a background report may be obtained for employment purposes. (15 U.S.C. § 1681b(b)(2))
  2. Get written authorization. The candidate must agree in writing before the report is run. The authorization can be on the same document as the disclosure.
  3. Send a pre-adverse action notice. Before deciding against someone based in whole or in part on the report, send them a copy of the report and a summary of their FCRA rights. (15 U.S.C. § 1681b(b)(3))
  4. Send an adverse action notice. After a final decision, notify the candidate as required by 15 U.S.C. § 1681m.

The FTC’s guidance for employers walks through each step, including how to securely dispose of reports afterward. Our plain-English FCRA overview for employers covers the same process in more depth.

Can employers ask for social media passwords?

No, not in 28 states. These laws generally bar employers from asking applicants or employees for usernames or passwords, asking them to lower their privacy settings, or asking them to log in to a personal account in front of the employer. (National Law Review, Oct 2025) New York is the most recent state to add a law, effective March 2024. (Ferretly’s state-by-state summary)

Public content is different. Many of these state laws say outright that it is not unlawful for employers to view publicly available social media. (Littler) Social media screening reviews public content only, and never asks for login credentials. Here’s what the state password laws actually say.

Can social media screening lead to discrimination claims?

Yes, if protected information influences the decision. Social media often shows things employers cannot legally consider, such as race, religion, age, disability, national origin or pregnancy. The EEOC has noted that viewing social media during hiring can reveal an applicant’s protected class status. (EEOC) Once a decision-maker has seen that information, it can be hard to prove it played no part.

The usual safeguard is separation: the person or provider who reviews social media is not the person who makes the hiring decision, and protected information is left out of what the decision-maker sees. (FindLaw)

Ferretly reports findings against criteria the employer defines. The employer decides what those findings mean and what, if anything, to do about them.

Can employers act on employees’ posts about work?

Sometimes not. Under Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act, employees, including non-union employees, have the right to act together on pay and working conditions. That can include social media posts and the conversations around them. (CalChamber) Employers should evaluate whether a work-related post is protected before taking action on it. A written social media conduct policy helps set expectations up front.

What should employers look for in a social media screening provider?

  • FCRA compliance: the provider operates as a consumer reporting agency, supports disclosure and authorization, and supports the adverse action process.
  • Public content only: no passwords, no private accounts, no fake friend requests.
  • Identity verification: the right person’s accounts are matched, so findings aren’t about someone with the same name.
  • Job-related criteria: the employer defines what to look for, such as threats, harassment, violence or illegal activity.
  • Protected information left out of what decision-makers see.
  • Human review where needed, with a way for candidates to dispute findings.

When it becomes risky

Social media screening drifts into risk when:

  • A decision-maker informally browses a candidate’s profile with no process
  • Protected-class information is captured into the decision
  • Private accounts are accessed or credentials are requested
  • Keyword hits are treated as conclusions without context or adjudication
  • No record exists of what was reviewed or why

In other words, the risk isn’t social media screening itself—it’s unstructured social media screening.

The questions below come from our webinar on the legal landscape of social media screening, featuring an employment attorney. Answers are summarized and focus on U.S. law. Watch the full session on demand.

Avoiding negligent hiring claims. When negligent hiring claims arise, they can be explosive. The question becomes whether the employer could have avoided the harm if they’d done more due diligence during hiring. Social media background checks offer a way to reduce that risk because they provide insight that might help an employer head off future harm. More in our negligent hiring liability guide.

Avoiding workplace harassers. Harassers are often repeat offenders. Social media can provide insight into whether someone is engaging in commentary or conduct that suggests they might create harassment issues in the workplace.

Reviewing existing employees. Employers can run social media background checks on current employees to identify potential harassment or other issues, such as one employee harassing another via social media. See where this fits in an insider risk program.

Does federal or state law bar the use of social media for screening employees?

There’s no federal law prohibiting employers from running social media background checks. 28 states have laws restricting employers from accessing private social media pages of applicants or employees. However, these laws don’t prevent employers from accessing publicly available social media information.

Some states, like California and New York, prohibit discrimination based on political affiliation, such as participating in a peaceful protest. But behavior like violent protest or harassment is not protected, and Ferretly lets users tailor which behaviors they surface to avoid running afoul of state laws.

Does social media screening raise concerns under Title VII or state discrimination laws?

Yes, it can if done poorly. Title VII prohibits workplace discrimination, harassment, and retaliation. One risk of social media review is exposing information about protected characteristics, such as religion, medical conditions, or union affiliation. Employers are better off not seeing this information because it could lead to accusations of discrimination. The best approach is to work with a professional screening service that filters out protected information and focuses on relevant behaviors.

Have courts faulted employers for not considering social media?

Those cases are starting to emerge. The Ninth Circuit considered a case involving an employee whose Instagram page promoted violent content, including specific threats toward a coworker. The court determined that the employer could be held liable for harassment even though the comments were made off-duty, concluding that employers must investigate social media content that bears on the terms and conditions of employment, even if it occurs outside the workplace.

Why should employers consider outsourcing social media background checks?

The number one reason is consistency. A store manager in one city might review candidates’ profiles very differently than a manager in another. Outsourcing applies the same rules across the organization. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), using a screening provider also gives candidates a mechanism to dispute incorrect findings, and a good provider filters out information employers shouldn’t see.

Does the FCRA apply to social media checks?

Yes, the FCRA applies when social media checks are conducted by a third party for employment purposes. It governs how background screening companies, known as consumer reporting agencies, and employers use and handle the information.

If the FCRA applies, what procedures must employers follow?

  1. Disclosure and written authorization. Employers must disclose that a background check will be conducted and obtain written authorization, in compliance with federal, state, and local laws.
  2. Adverse action process. Before taking adverse action based on the report, the employer issues a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and a summary of rights, allows time for the individual to dispute inaccuracies, and then sends a final notice if it proceeds.

When should employers incorporate social media screening into hiring?

It depends on the employer’s goals and risk tolerance. Some screen at the conditional offer stage, aligning with how criminal checks are typically handled. Others screen earlier. The best approach balances compliance, risk management, and organizational needs.

Has the distinction between public and private social media been litigated?

Generally, content accessible without a login is considered fair game, while content behind a password or shared privately is typically off-limits unless the individual consents. A recent Ninth Circuit case described public social media as content accessible without a login.

How do you avoid misjudging behavior across cultures and generations?

A screening provider shouldn’t make judgments. It applies predefined classifications—such as hate speech, violence, or prejudice—and surfaces content that matches them. Employers then evaluate flagged content against their own values, culture, and policies.

Is there a use case for a social media check that doesn’t fall under the FCRA?

The FCRA generally applies to employment, licensing, insurance, and credit purposes. Monitoring the reputation of a public figure who represents a brand could fall outside it. Many organizations still assume the FCRA applies to err on the side of caution.

Does the FCRA apply to volunteer checks?

The general consensus is yes. Federal advisory opinions have interpreted the employment purpose broadly enough to include volunteers, so it’s safest to assume compliance is required.

Can screening be used during an internal investigation?

Depending on context, yes. Screening can be part of an internal investigation into concerns about a coworker’s conduct. If the issue involves litigation after the employee has left, the permissible purpose becomes less clear and counsel should be consulted.

What does the dispute process look like?

  1. The individual disputes the report’s accuracy or completeness.
  2. The provider reinvestigates, focusing on the match (is this the right person?) or the content (is the finding accurate?).
  3. The provider communicates the results to both the individual and the employer.

FAQ

Is it legal for employers to look at my social media? Yes, if the content is public. If an employer uses a screening company for a hiring decision, it must tell you and get your written permission first.

Can employers ask for my social media password? Not in 28 states. Those laws generally bar employers from asking for usernames or passwords, asking applicants to lower privacy settings, or asking them to log in to a personal account in front of the employer.

Can I be rejected because of what I post online? You can be rejected for job-related conduct, such as threats or harassment. You cannot be rejected because of a protected characteristic, such as your religion or a disability, and in many cases not for discussing working conditions with coworkers.

Do I have the right to see a social media background report? Yes. Before an employer takes adverse action based on the report, it must give you a copy and a summary of your rights. You can dispute anything that is inaccurate.

Is social media screening legal outside the US? Rules differ by country. The UK, EU and Canada have their own privacy and data protection laws, so the process has to follow local requirements. See Ferretly’s UK and EU page for details.

The bottom line

Social media screening is legal when it uses public content, follows the FCRA, keeps protected information out of the decision, and leaves the decision with the employer. The legality lives in the method. For the full process, see our complete guide to social media background checks, or book a demo to see how Ferretly builds those guardrails into the workflow.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and change over time.

View full blog

Protect Your Brand. Prevent the Fallout.

Discover how Ferretly can help you make informed decisions about who you work with, partner with, or hire.